… Says 100 Germans also died during the 1904-08 genocide on Namibian soil
By Kaundjire Humbu
German lawmaker and leader of the Alternative for Germany (AfD), Alexander Wolf, has challenged the recognition of the genocide committed against the OvaHerero and Nama people during German colonial rule.
He instead argues that Germany should focus on future relations with Namibia rather than reparations.
Wolf made the remarks in the German Bundestag on Wednesday during a debate on motions tabled by Die Linke and the Greens concerning Germany’s colonial history in Namibia.
He accused Die Linke of using Germany’s colonial past to promote what he described as German “selfhatred” and demands for reparations, arguing that the country’s relationship with Namibia should not be determined by left-wing ideology.
“Our relationship with Namibia is a special one for historical reasons,” Wolf said, referring to Namibia’s former status as German South West Africa until Germany lost its colonies following the First World War.
“When it comes to Namibia, we should look forward, not back,” Wolf said.
The debate focused on proposals seeking further action by the German government regarding colonial-era crimes committed between 1904 and 1908.
In his speech, Wolf addressed the 1904 uprising by the OvaHerero against German colonial rule, which was followed by military campaigns against the OvaHerero and Nama.
He said more than 100 German traders, farmers, women and children were killed during the uprising, describing the subsequent conflict as a war that caused suffering on both sides.
Wolf referred to the deaths of thousands of OvaHerero during their retreat into the arid interior, attributing many of the deaths to thirst.
He also acknowledged the harsh military campaign led by General Lothar von Trotha.
He argued that von Trotha’s military methods were criticised at the time and that his extermination order was rescinded by Kaiser Wilhelm II in 1904 following intervention by German Chancellor Bernhard von Bülow.
Wolf used these events to challenge the classification of the atrocities as genocide, claiming that the interpretation was influenced by political interests.
He alleged that British wartime propaganda helped establish the genocide narrative through the publication of the Blue Book, which documented German colonial administration in South West Africa.
According to Wolf, the report was used during negotiations following the First World War to portray Germany as incapable of administering colonies and justify the removal of its colonial territories.
He claimed that the British later withdrew the document after achieving their objectives.
Wolf criticised German historian Horst Drechsler, whose 1966 study examined German colonial rule in Namibia, accusing him of presenting the country’s colonial history through a communist ideological framework.
He further criticised German historians and politicians who support recognition of the genocide, arguing that their positions reinforced what he described as an ideological interpretation of the colonial period.
Die Linke’s motion called on the German government to acknowledge its historical responsibility and legal liability for the genocide against the OvaHerero and Nama.
The party called for reparations to be directed towards descendants of the victims, arguing that development assistance to Namibia should not replace compensation for colonial crimes.
Its proposals also included renewed negotiations with representatives of the affected communities, the return of land and territories, and the repatriation of cultural objects and human remains held in German collections.
The Greens also called for Germany to recognise the genocide committed between 1904 and 1908 against the Ova-Herero, Nama, Damara and San communities.
Their motion called for an official apology to Namibia and descendants of the victims, the return of cultural objects and human remains, and joint efforts to address Germany’s colonial history.
The debate comes five years after Germany announced in 2021 that it intended to ask Namibia and descendants of the victims for forgiveness for atrocities committed during the colonial period.
The two governments initialled a joint declaration addressing the genocide and Germany’s historical responsibility.
However, the proposed arrangement has faced criticism from representatives of affected communities over the negotiations and the reparations framework.
Between 1904 and 1908, German colonial forces waged war against the OvaHerero and Nama, with military campaigns, forced displacement and confinement in camps resulting in mass deaths.
Germany has recognised the atrocities as genocide, making the issue central to discussions between the two countries on historical responsibility and reconciliation.
Wolf argued that demands for reparations could create divisions between Germany and Namibia, as well as among communities within Namibia.
He also accused Die Linke of adopting what he described as a neo-colonial approach by seeking to determine how Namibia should address its colonial history.
Wolf called for relations between the two countries to be based on equality and cooperation, while acknowledging their shared history.
“We should rather look to the future, cultivate good German-Namibian relations, on equal footing, in awareness of our responsibility,” he said.
The motions by Die Linke and the Greens were referred to the Bundestag’s Foreign affairs committee for further consideration following the debate.
Landless People’s Movement (LPM, human rights officer Joyce Muzengua) said reparations remain owed directly to the affected communities.
“The reparations are owed to the Herero and the Nama. It is very important that the German government understands that,” Muzengua said.”
“They can have their relationship with the Namibian government, because the Namibian government is not comprised of OvaHereros and Namas alone, it is comprised of all Namibians. So that relationship can continue, that is fine. But that does not negate the fact that Germany has a legal responsibility to pay reparations owed to the Nama and Herero communities.”
She added: “Whatever else Germany wants to do with the Namibian government is not our business. We are going to deal with what we are owed as reparations”.
Namibia Economic Freedom Fighters (NEFF) deputy leader and member of parliament Kalimbo Ipumbu said Namibia does not require Germany’s permission to recognise its own history. Ipumbu said the atrocities committed under German colonial rule form part of Namibia’s historical reality and cannot be erased through political statements or attempts to reinterpret history.
“Namibia does not need permission from Berlin to remember its own history. Our history belongs to us. Our ancestors experienced it, our communities preserved it, and no foreign parliament has the authority to rewrite it,” Ipumbu said.
He also rejected suggestions that confronting Germany’s colonial past could undermine relations between the two countries, arguing that genuine reconciliation must be grounded in historical truth, justice and dignity.
Ipumbu further warned that Namibia should guard against colonialism resurfacing through economic domination, particularly as foreign interest grows in the country’s minerals, renewable energy, oil, gas and green hydrogen sectors.
“We reject colonialism in its old form and we will equally reject any attempt to reproduce it through economic domination. Green hydrogen, minerals, land and other strategic resources must benefit Namibians first. Foreign investors cannot take the resources while Namibia is left with unemployment, poverty and inequality,” he added.
Ipumbu said Namibia should engage Germany and other international partners as an equal sovereign state.
“We will not allow our history to be rewritten. We will not allow our resources to be exploited without meaningful benefit to Namibians. We will not allow green hydrogen to become green colonialism. Namibia is no longer German South-West Africa. Namibia is a sovereign African nation, and Namibians must determine their own future.”





